Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic helped revive the franchise’s fortunes in games and changed BioWare’s trajectory. Alex Kane’s Boss Fight book tells the story of its production, but this review finds that the roughly 100-page volume only scratches the surface.
A cinematic RPG built for Xbox
BioWare designed Knights of the Old Republic as a flagship game for the original Xbox. Unlike the studio’s earlier computer RPGs, which relied on point-and-click controls, this one had to feel at home on a console. Its combat was technically turn-based, but the presentation aimed for the immediacy of an action game.
The result was a fully voiced, cinematic role-playing game that made a strong impression even on journalists with little interest in Star Wars. The review credits the game with delivering a memorable story and a major plot twist, while avoiding spoilers.
Knights of the Old Republic made a CRPG combat system work as a console game without losing its cinematic ambition.
How the book handles the story
Kane focuses mainly on the game’s production. The reviewer praises some of the details, including the story of actor Ed Asner joining the voice cast, but finds the book short on perspective about BioWare’s working culture and the creative pressures behind the project.
Other Boss Fight books, the review argues, offer context that helps illuminate how teams build games under deadlines. Here, several potentially rich subjects receive only brief attention, leaving the account less revealing than it could have been.
A legacy with a cost
The book also prompts reflection on how Knights of the Old Republic shaped BioWare’s later games. The studio went on to create Dragon Age and Mass Effect, but their increasingly cinematic ambitions drew on a template first developed for a Star Wars license it could only use temporarily.
That legacy feels complicated in retrospect. The review suggests that the game helped make major releases feel like events, while the growing demands of cinematic production have brought tighter constraints and larger budgets across the industry.
Verdict
Knights of the Old Republic remains a significant milestone in RPG and Star Wars history, and Kane’s account contains worthwhile moments. But the review’s verdict is ultimately one of disappointment: the book recounts the production without digging deeply enough into the people, decisions, and wider consequences that made the game matter.
• Subject: The making and legacy of Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
• Book: Alex Kane’s Boss Fight volume, published in 2019
• Verdict: Interesting in places, but too brief and lacking depth
The book tells an important story, but leaves too many of its most interesting angles unexplored.
Source: Old School Gamer Magazine




